The Indian Rupee (INR) and the Vietnamese Dong (VND) are two currencies that represent two of the fastest-growing economies in Asia. India, with its massive population and growing economic influence, and Vietnam, which has seen remarkable economic growth in the last few decades, have become important players in regional trade. However, while both countries are economically intertwined through trade and investment, the question of whether the Indian Rupee can be used directly in Vietnam is complex and multi-faceted. This article seeks to explore the feasibility, challenges, and potential impact of using the Indian Rupee in Vietnam.
The Indian Rupee and the Vietnamese Dong: A Brief Overview
Before diving into the question of currency usage, it’s essential to understand the context of both the Indian Rupee and the Vietnamese Dong. The Indian Rupee, abbreviated as INR, is the official currency of India, and it is managed by the Reserve Bank of India (RBI). The INR is used primarily within India, though it is also traded in international markets, especially in countries with significant Indian diaspora populations. However, the Indian Rupee is not a fully convertible currency on the global market, meaning it cannot be freely exchanged for other currencies without restrictions.
The Vietnamese Dong, abbreviated as VND, is the official currency of Vietnam, and it is issued by the State Bank of Vietnam. Unlike the INR, the VND is tightly controlled by the Vietnamese government in terms of its exchange rate and usage within the country. The Dong is not widely traded in international markets, and Vietnam maintains a system of managed exchange rates with the currencies that it exchanges most frequently, such as the US Dollar (USD), the Euro (EUR), and other major Asian currencies.
The Indian Rupee’s International Status
For the Indian Rupee to be used directly in another country, it must first achieve a certain level of international acceptance. A currency’s international status is determined by several factors, including its liquidity, the volume of trade conducted in the currency, and its stability.
Currently, the Indian Rupee is not widely accepted for direct transactions outside of India, with the exception of some countries that have significant trade relations with India or have a large Indian diaspora. In most of these instances, trade is conducted using more stable and widely recognized currencies, such as the US Dollar, the Euro, or the Japanese Yen. The Indian government and the Reserve Bank of India have been making efforts to internationalize the INR through initiatives like the India International Bank (Singapore), which enables INR transactions in specific markets, and the establishment of INR trading hubs in countries like Mauritius and the UAE. However, despite these efforts, the Indian Rupee is far from being a global reserve currency or one that can be easily used for trade in foreign markets like the US Dollar or the Euro.
In order for the Indian Rupee to be used in Vietnam, it would need to be accepted by the Vietnamese government, banks, and businesses, and there would need to be sufficient mechanisms for exchanging INR for VND. This is where several challenges arise.
The Current State of Indian-Vietnamese Trade
India and Vietnam share a strong economic relationship, with trade between the two countries growing steadily over the past two decades. The two countries are members of several multilateral trade organizations, including the ASEAN-India Free Trade Area (AIFTA), which has boosted trade in goods and services. According to data from India’s Ministry of Commerce, bilateral trade between India and Vietnam reached over $13 billion in 2022, with both countries striving to increase trade to $15 billion by 2025.
Despite this growing trade relationship, the Indian Rupee is not typically used for transactions between Indian and Vietnamese businesses. The most common method of settling trade deals is through the US Dollar or the Chinese Yuan. This is because both the INR and the VND are not freely convertible and are subject to government controls, which makes it more challenging for businesses to rely on them for cross-border trade. Instead, the use of widely accepted international currencies such as the USD helps mitigate exchange rate risks and provides a more stable means of transaction.
Vietnamese businesses and banks typically do not hold or deal in Indian Rupees, and the Vietnamese central bank does not provide an exchange rate for the INR. This makes it difficult for Indian companies or individuals to conduct transactions in the Indian Rupee when doing business in Vietnam. The absence of INR trading pairs in the Vietnamese foreign exchange market further complicates the situation.
The Challenge of Currency Convertibility
One of the biggest barriers to using the Indian Rupee in Vietnam is the issue of currency convertibility. Convertibility refers to a currency’s ability to be exchanged for another currency without restrictions. Both the Indian Rupee and the Vietnamese Dong are non-convertible currencies, meaning that they cannot be easily exchanged on the global market or at market-determined rates.
In the case of the INR, the Reserve Bank of India enforces strict controls over its convertibility. Indian citizens are allowed to exchange INR for foreign currencies within the prescribed limits, and businesses can also engage in foreign exchange transactions through authorized dealers. However, these restrictions make it difficult for INR to be used in countries like Vietnam, where it is not a widely recognized or accepted currency.
Similarly, the Vietnamese Dong is subject to restrictions imposed by the State Bank of Vietnam. The Vietnamese government controls the exchange rate of the Dong and has established a managed float system. The VND is not traded freely on the open market, and there is limited foreign exchange liquidity for currencies other than the US Dollar or major Asian currencies like the Japanese Yen or Chinese Yuan.
For the Indian Rupee to be used in Vietnam, the Vietnamese government would need to establish a system for exchanging the INR with the VND. This would require significant changes in the foreign exchange market, including the establishment of trading pairs for INR/VND and the creation of infrastructure to support INR transactions.
Potential Benefits of Using the Indian Rupee in Vietnam
While the idea of using the Indian Rupee in Vietnam faces several challenges, there could be several potential benefits for both countries if such a system were to be developed.
Reduced Currency Conversion Costs: For Indian businesses operating in Vietnam, the ability to use the Indian Rupee directly could reduce the costs associated with currency conversion. Currently, Indian businesses have to convert INR to US Dollars, which are then converted to Vietnamese Dong. By eliminating the need for multiple conversions, the overall cost of doing business could be reduced.
Increased Trade Efficiency: Using the Indian Rupee directly could make trade between India and Vietnam more efficient. For example, businesses could settle contracts directly in INR, reducing the need for third-party financial intermediaries. This could help streamline payment processes and improve trade relations between the two countries.
Strengthening Bilateral Relations: The use of the Indian Rupee in Vietnam could signal a deeper level of economic cooperation between the two countries. It would demonstrate a commitment to expanding economic ties and could lead to the development of more robust trade and investment channels.
Political and Economic Considerations
The decision to allow the use of the Indian Rupee in Vietnam would ultimately depend on both political and economic considerations. For the Indian government, the primary concern would be whether the use of INR abroad would have any adverse effects on the Indian economy. Allowing INR to be used in countries like Vietnam could increase the demand for the currency, but it could also lead to greater volatility in its exchange rate if not carefully managed.
On the Vietnamese side, the government would need to consider the potential impact of introducing INR into its economy. Vietnam is heavily reliant on foreign trade, and any significant fluctuations in the exchange rate between the INR and the VND could impact its trade balance. Additionally, Vietnam would need to ensure that its foreign exchange policies and regulations can accommodate the use of INR without causing instability in the currency markets.
Conclusion
While it is unlikely that the Indian Rupee will become a widely used currency in Vietnam in the immediate future, there is potential for greater cooperation between the two countries in the area of currency usage. The complexities of currency convertibility, foreign exchange regulations, and the lack of infrastructure for INR transactions in Vietnam make it challenging for the Indian Rupee to be used directly in trade. However, with continued economic growth in both countries and potential improvements in trade relations, it is not outside the realm of possibility that we may see some movement towards greater use of the Indian Rupee in Vietnam in the future.
At present, the most practical solution for Indian and Vietnamese businesses remains to use widely accepted international currencies such as the US Dollar or the Chinese Yuan. However, both countries could explore bilateral agreements or initiatives to facilitate the use of the Indian Rupee in trade, which would provide tangible benefits for businesses in both nations.
Related Topics:
